Previous Next

Integral facsimiles of the illustrations by Gustave Doré to Dante Alighieri's "Inferno", part of the "Divine Comedy"
Index

View pictures:
Alighieri's scientific cosmology :

The "Divine Comedy" is poetry which attempts to describe hard scientific facts and not symbolic meaning. It describes the astronomical consequences of literal Christian faith in medieval times. The naïve trust in every word of the old and the new testament. The truth is physical and spiritual in the same way. No gap in between. Not yet! Not for another 300 years.

The teachings of Plato (427-347 BC), Aristotle (384-322 BC), Ptolemy (87 -150 AD), Augustine (354-430), Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) culimate in Dante's cosmology. It is a strictly Ptolemaic universe consisting of concentric spheres. The earth with the humans is in the middle. The heavens around it, the outer sphere is God's throne. Inside the earth is hell. Satan resides in the center of our globe. We, the humans are geometrically between heaven and hell, torn between God and Satan.

This is the top of medieval Christian belief, the top of scholastics. Of course, this belief collapsed in face of its obvious inconsistencies with upcoming scientific research based on observation and experience. The church was in a bad situation defending the big clean theory against observations such as those made though Galileo Galilei's (1564-1642) telescope. The cardinals at that time refused to look at the moons circling Jupiter.

The moons of Jupiter

They believed that Christian faith would collapse, all humans would instantly kill each other and the devil would take care of the last killers - if earth were not the center of God's creation and if there were maybe other "earths" and "moons". Of course, a faith like Christianism lives from ideas, from words and human understanding and not from rocks flying through space. But the medieval cardinals did not trust the core of their faith. In fact the master of scholastic theology, Thomas Aquinus had emphasised that our pictures of God and its creation are just pictures and do not equal "facts of God". But these warnings and their consequences were not understood at his time. (HK)

The Moons of Jupiter :

Galileo observed 4 points of light that changed their positions with time around the planet Jupiter. He concluded that these were objects in orbit around Jupiter. Indeed, they were the 4 brightest moons of Jupiter, which are now commonly called the Galilean moons (Galileo himself called them the Medicea Siderea - the "Medician Stars"). These observations again showed that there were new things in the heavens that Aristotle and Ptolemy had known nothing about. Furthermore, they demonstrated that a planet could have moons circling it that would not be left behind as the planet moved around its orbit. One of the arguments against the Copernican system (and the original heliocentric idea of Aristarchus) had been that if the moon were in orbit around the Earth and the Earth in orbit around the Sun, the Earth would leave the Moon behind as it moved around its orbit. (NASA)

previous page | next page